This matrix, named after stuart pugh, is commonly used to evaluate design concept alternatives though it need not exclusively be used in these applications, we are going to demonstrate the use in a concept selection decision. Named after its creator, stewart pugh, a british design engineer, the pugh matrix varies from the generic decision matrix in a couple ways. So lets see how it works for our lunch example weve set up our matrix as shown above by listing our four options on the horizontal axis and our decision. Macrobased decision matrix article and download from the time atlas productivity portfolio. The pugh matrix pm is a type of matrix diagram 1 that allows for the comparison of a number of design candidates leading ultimately to which best meets a set of criteria. You then score each optionfactor combination, weight this score by the relative importance of the factor, and add these scores up to give an overall score for each option. Several concepts are evaluated according to their strengths and weaknesses against a reference concept called the datum base concept.
That means qfd is generally used at the requirement stage, to choose the best set of requirements. Pugh matrix analysis can be used to select the best concept from a set of. It is a scoring matrix used for concept selection in which options are assigned scores relative to criteria. Jun 22, 2015 pugh matrix concept evaluation in design 1. It is also necessary that team members have enough knowledge about the problem, if possible have team members that belongs from the affected department. The pugh matrix pm is a type of matrix diagram 1 that allows for the comparison of a number. Pugh matrix is a diagram that is used to evaluate alternative solutions for business. Microsoft education licensing solutions partner gold authorised education partner gold volume licensing. Pugh concept selection matrix in excel six sigma software. Number of alternate solution concepts attempting to satisfy the need.
A datum is a reference decision, a reference architecture. It is important to note that there is no voting in pugh s method. The application of pugh matrix in these cases resulted in exploring more and farther reaching alternate design than in the normal practice. You can reuse the data from a previous matrix, like the houseofquality. Sigma magic software is an easy to use excel based data analysis software that can be used. Gap analysis matrix enterprise architect user guide. Professor pugh s example is used by several authors who teach the pugh method in their design texts. Evaluate each concept against the datum for each of the criteria. A benchmark or datum is selected, usually the best existing product. The method was invented by stuart pugh, university of strathclyde in glasgow, scotland as an approach for selecting concept alternatives.
When completed, the pugh concept selection method can appear complex. The use of the baseline indicates whether the option will positively improve or negatively subtract from what is currently in place. In the pugh matrix you will compare how effectively different design alternatives will satisfy the stated requirements. These are used for evaluating multiple options against each other, in relation to a baseline option. Factoring in relative weights of the criteria, we see that pizza delivery is still the best option when weighted, at six pluses and two minuses. If the design is better than the datum it will get a positive number and the magnitude of the number depends on how much. Morphological analysis is another form of a decision matrix employing a multidimensional configuration space linked by way of logical relationships. The pugh matrix is designed to assess multicriterion project.
The pugh matrix is a tool used to facilitate a disciplined, teambased process for concept generation and selection. It can mean that the experts agree that the concepts merit is similar to the datum or that the differences between the concept and the datum are controversial and cannot be determined yet. Jun 19, 2007 a morphological matrix will help identify potential solutions and define functional requirements for each solution. The weighted decision matrix is a very simple tool designed to help anybody make a decision e. It helps you to determine which solutions are more valuable than the others. Use a pugh concept selection matrix to evaluate various design alternatives against an existing baseline. Criteria weighting baseline survey form emea archer tool category criteria supplier relationships are measured on a percentage basis 0 supplier relationships are measured on actuals e. Sophisticated mcda can involve highly complex modeling of different potential scenarios, using advanced mathematics. Background calculations pugh matrix pugh concept selection matix criteria rating sum of positives sum of negatives sum of sames weighted sum of positives. Get information and other solutions to define your tender, in relation to free pugh matrix excel template. It is also called a variety of names including pugh method, pugh analysis, decision matrix method, decision matrix, decision grid, selection grid, selection matrix, problem matrix. Grid analysis comprehensive article from the mind tools site. Concepts come from the combinations you made in the morph matrix size weight capacity s. A category score is calculated by summing the weighted scores for each criterion in the category and dividing by the sum of the weights for the criteria in the category.
Selecting the appropriate datum is important because every solution will be evaluated against the datum. Decision matrix analysis works by getting you to list your options as rows on a table, and the factors you need consider as columns. Here is an example of a decision matrix and here is a free copy of a grid analysis worksheet. Fashion plm rfp template available tec analyst, kurt chen, recently completed work on a new research segment covering product lifecycle management plm selection criteria for the fashion industry. The pugh matrix is an easytouse, group decisionmaking tool that assesses alternatives against performance criteria. Decision matrix analysis decisionmaking skills from. A pugh matrix will help rank potential solutions against the voice of the customer voc. It was originally used to evaluate and select between several product or. Pugh matrix the pugh matrix is used to compare combinations of solutions for each function to a datum. Sep 24, 2012 one method, called pugh method, helps engineers in design decisions by establishing a procedure to choose the best design from the considered designs. Our last blog discussed unweighted decision matrix. If you are a graduate, seeking an opportunity for an apprenticeship or work experience then get in touch with us.
It does have some pitfalls, as well, but its very well known. Criteria weighting baseline survey form emea archer tool category criteria supplier relationships are measured on a percentage basis 0. Decision matrix analysis is the simplest form of multiple criteria decision analysis mcda, also known as multiple criteria decision aid or multiple criteria decision management mcdm. Chua has trained thousands of executives, managers, and. This file comes with a blank template as well as a completed matrix for a home burglar system concept selection. The datum should be a somewhat average design not the best or worst idea. A matrix that used at for the evaluation individual employee skill as requirements to identify contingency requirements, for the improvement individual. Stuart pugh, a wellknown inventor in the field of product development and design, management and engineering created a methodical technique that helped identify the most probable solution among all alternatives. Triptych pugh matrix worksheet allows you to rate and rank multiple userdefined design options against multiple userdefined criteria using the qualitative pugh matrix approach. Decision tools provide an ideal way to evaluate and select vendors and.
Finer rating scales can be used, such as 2, 1, 0, 1. Pugh matrix worksheet is used to make fast qualitative comparisons when design options and design criteria are known. The pugh matrix helps establish the criteria that are important to you and your team. One method is to examine which software they currently use. Purchase decisions dont have to be based on the cheapest solution nor do you have to adapt your processes and. Gartner decision tools deliver software applications, services and methodologies that enable users to calculate and compare return on. Pugh are always on the lookout for talented and enthusiastic individuals to join our team. After the datum, list down all the alternative solutions horizontally.
The pugh concept promotes comparison of a number of different models against the. The pugh matrix helps determine which items or potential solutions are more important or better than others. Excellent for both professional and personal decisionmaking. It is employed after capturing voice of the customer voc. The pugh matrix aims to bring out the strengths and weaknesses and select the best ideas that come closest to meeting customer requirements.
Several concepts are evaluated according to their strengths and weaknesses against a reference concept called the datum. A pugh matrix assists in evaluating multiple ideas or design concepts against each other in relation to a baseline, or datum. The pugh matrix, designed by professor stuart pugh, answers the question, which option will most improve what is in place now. Difficultiesissues limited knowledge data conceptual solutions roughabstract ideas consensus among team members other 3.
Datascene is a data graphing, animation, and analysis software. Let us consider a situation in which several experts claim that a concept is better than the datum and others disagree. Pugh matrix concept evaluation in design slideshare. Pugh decisionmaking method is a clever way to make decisions. Establish a baseline, which may be one of the alternatives or the current product or service. Muenchen cited a survey conducted by rexer analytics about the relative popularity of various data analysis software in 2010. Selection of software for solving big data problems 754 employers seek.
May 11, 2015 you can make effective decision tree diagrams and slides in powerpoint using builtin powerpoint features like shapes and connectors. This method is also known as decisionmatrix method or pugh concept selection. The creation of criteria and alternatives will depend on the project members. The systems engineering tool box burge hughes walsh. In this blog, we are going to look at a weighted version called the pugh matrix. Professor pughs example is used by several authors who teach the pugh method in their design texts. Select one of your concepts as the datum most likely the current or the. Purpose the purpose of this paper is to define and describe pugh matrix analysis as a method for decision making when there are multiple criteria that must be factored into a decision. Features create and manage a pugh matrix with up to 200 criteria and 200 options. We developed a free interactive online software inspired by pugh s original matrix that helps you make fast choices. It is frequently used in engineering for making design decisions but can also be used to rank investment options, vendor options, product options or any other set of multidimensional entities. Pugh matrix top 7 decision tree powerpoint templates.
Selection of statistical software for data scientists and. The pugh matrix is a criteriabased decision matrix which uses criteria scoring to determine which of several potential solutions or alternatives should be selected. The datum is the best current concept at each iteration of the matrix. Typically, a pugh matrix is used to evaluate various alternatives against a baseline. A matrix that used at for the evaluation individual employee skill as requirements to identify contingency requirements, for the. The pugh matrix is a decision matrix thats a key six sigma tool when used as part of a pugh analysis. Looking at the tally totals at the bottom of the matrix, we see that pizza delivery has two pluses, one minus, and one s. Each option is rated as better than, same as, or worse than a datum for each criterion.
To draw a pugh chart, list the design criteria in the left column. Pdf application of pugh selection matrix for fuel level. The pugh matrix is a criteriabased decision matrix which uses criteria scoring to determine which of. The systems engineering tool box dr stuart burge give us the tools and we will finish the job winston churchill pugh matrix pm what is it and what does it do. The datum concept is usually the productservice used currently. Regardless, in an attempt to clarify the relative strengths and weaknesses of each concept, the students created a second matrix using the agitator as the new datum. You could also select the best in class as the datum. It is a structured approach used by a team to subjectively evaluate each concept based on a given set of evaluation criteria to select the best concept. The pugh matrix pm is a type of matrix diagram that allows for the. Whereas pugh matrix is used at the deployement stage, i. The pugh matrix, named after stuart pugh, is a decision aid for evaluating competing concepts in comparison to a basic concept. For example, an innovation team might have many ideas about how to whiten teeth using new technologies. In pugh s method, s can denote two different situations.
Decision trees are a powerful business tool that can help you to describe the logic behind a business decision and offers and effective and systematic method to document your decisions outcome and decision making process. This method does not require a massive amount of quantitative data. If no comparable product exists, one of the new concepts. The decision matrix method, also pugh method or pugh concept selection, invented by stuart pugh, is a qualitative technique used to rank the multidimensional options of an option set. Concept evaluationselection in design by yogesh prasad 2.
You can pugh compare the voice of the customer with design alternatives design concepts. Richard chua is a consultant, author, professor, and certified lean six sigma master black belt trainer. Is typically used in teams can just as easily be used by individuals. By understanding the roi of technology investments, clients are equipped with data to support their it investment strategy. Sometimes, once you get the answer from the pugh matrix, you can set the solution as the datum and redo the analysis again just to reconfirm your solution. An interesting variation in team decisionmaking is for each individual to create his own pew matrix and then as a team the pugh matrices are compared. About the pugh decision matrix article on the lean software engineering site. The pugh matrix is a useful tool for comparing the concepts that support a product or service with actual customer needs and internal functional requirements. Create matrix with custom number of criteria and alternatives grouping of decision criteria for ease of use weight column provided to increase importance.
Pugh matrices are superbly crafted tools for teambuilding and consensus finding. Pugh analysis overview pugh matrix analysis can be used to select the best concept from a set of competing concepts. Difficultiesissues limited knowledgedata conceptual solutions roughabstract. Then list the design alternatives across the first row. Evaluate all your design concepts to create the invincible solution. Snapsheets xl fmea, qfd, and pugh software for excel. Then, rate how well each design meets each design criteria relative to the. Decision matrix as a tool for making decisions web resources. The gap analysis matrix is a convenient tool for analyzing model artifacts to identify potential gaps between solution architectures the idea is to highlight a shortfall between the baseline architecture and the target architecture. This process requires that a good datum be selected. There are variations of the method however im going to explain here how i use it. Learn about working at datum software inc join linkedin today for free. A decision matrix evaluates and prioritizes a list of options and is a decisionmaking tool.
Eventually, the pugh matrix will lead the team to choose the best solution for each function, creating the ideal system design. In pugh s method, a discussion proceeds in which the experts on both sides. And this is named after stuart pugh, who is a british professor of design, essentially. Pugh matrix, decision grid, selection matrix or grid, problem matrix, problem selection matrix, opportunity analysis, solution matrix, criteria rating form, criteriabased matrix. This will create a matrix with the criteria on the vertical axis and the solutions on the horizontal axis.
Datum is considered the paramount model on every iteration of the medium. It also permits a degree of qualitative optimisation of the alternative concepts through the generation of hybrid candidates. Posted on may 11, 2015 november 6, 2017 you can make effective decision tree diagrams and slides in powerpoint. We have rearranged and simplified the example to bring out some points we want to make more clearly. May 03, 2015 a pugh matrix is a selection tool used to help choose between multiple concepts for a new process, product, or service. One of the most powerful and effective tools for selecting the best tool or product to purchase is the pugh selection matrix. The pugh matrix was developed by stuart pugh who was a professor and head of the design division at the university of strathclyde in glasgow. That being said i would advice not to do a pugh matrix for just 2 designs, in practice something between 3 to 7 designs could be compared.
421 887 111 650 1167 965 104 1143 1147 557 299 435 481 1044 610 1107 1386 730 508 362 619 717 1285 251 529 325 1032 302 1030 1041 507 806 1431 428 989 1294 651 1475 971 1417 93 389 273 1105 1364